Exhaust fumes only third of traffic pollution problem
4 June 2013 by Alex Peel
Vehicle exhausts are responsible for only a third of traffic pollution, according to new research.
The study, published in Atmospheric Environment, says nearly half of air pollution from road traffic is down to non-exhaust sources such as brake wear, road-surface wear, and particles whipped up from the road by passing vehicles.
Professor Ranjeet Sokhi, of the University of Hertfordshire, who led the study, is calling for greater control of non-exhaust pollution.
"In terms of mass, non-exhaust sources can be more important than exhaust fumes, but legislative control has focused on exhaust emissions," he says.
"As exhaust regulations become stricter, non-exhaust sources become proportionately more important. Continuing to control exhaust emissions alone may not be enough to achieve legal air-quality standards."
The team took air samples from the Hatfield Tunnel on the A1 (M) in Hertfordshire. They were interested in airborne pollution particles less than 10 millionths of a metre across.
Pollution particles of that size, known as PM10, are linked with long-term health problems, including heart disease.
Continuing to control exhaust emissions alone may not be enough to achieve legal air-quality standards
- Professor Ranjeet Sokhi, University of Hertfordshire
"Other studies have looked at non-exhaust components of PM10, but those have mostly been done in open-air locations," explains Sokhi. "We wanted to look at them in a more controlled environment, where the influence of the weather could be significantly reduced."
"The Hatfield tunnel provided an ideal laboratory; you are protected from the elements and it confines the airborne particles, making it easier to collect sufficient material for analysis."
Back in the lab, samples were separated out into their chemical components. By analysing these, scientists were able to calculate where up to 82 per cent of the pollution in the samples had come from.
Petrol and diesel exhausts are responsible for only 33 per cent of the particles. 27 per cent are whipped up from the road by vehicles, while brake and road surface wear account for 11 per cent each.
Road traffic is thought to be the most important source of air pollution in the UK. As well as the health effects, poor air quality is estimated to cost the UK economy up to £16 billion every year.
Parts of London regularly struggle to meet EU air-quality standards. In 2010, Transport for London began spraying a calcite glue solution onto roads, in an attempt to stick pollution to the road surface.
Launching the programme, Mayor Boris Johnson said it was "a wonderful contraption that tackles air quality head on." But a recent study by scientists at King's College London has questioned the effectiveness of the scheme.
"It is important to recognise that controlling non-exhaust emissions is more difficult; a number of different approaches might be needed," says Sokhi.
"Where possible, new technologies and other pollution reduction options should be investigated. These might include, for example, new materials for tyres and brakes and different methods for constructing road surfaces."
The study was part of a PhD project undertaken by Samantha Lawrence. It was funded by NERC and the British Oxygen Company (BOC).
'Source apportionment of traffic emissions of particulate matter using tunnel measurements' - S Lawrence, R Sokhi, K Ravindra, H Mao, H Douglas Prain, ID Bull, Atmospheric Environment, 2013, DOI: 10.1016/j.atmosenv.2013.03.040.